Stage 1 is done and its output is provably wrong in nine places: binaries asking for libgpgme.so.11, libnettle.so.8, libicuuc.so.76 and six more at the HOST's soname versions. Stage 2 dissolves all nine by rebuilding each package against what the repository actually ships. The constraint that shapes it: pacman cannot run inside the stage-1 rootfs, because libalpm was linked against the host's gpgme. So the rootfs is populated from OUTSIDE, with the host's pacman and --root, and the chroot is used only to build. That is not a workaround, it is the order the problem has -- stage 2's own output is the first pacman that will run on the target. Five packages were added to stage 1 for this, and the resolver could never have named them: nothing DEPENDS on fakeroot or bison, they are simply what a build needs to happen. makepkg refuses to run as root, so the chroot carries a user with the host's uid -- a bind mount keeps the numeric owner, and a different uid inside could not write $srcdir. The smoke test separates hard failures from known drift. makeinfo fails because texinfo was built against the host's perl; that is what stage 2 repairs, so refusing to start over it would refuse to run the fix. --- FR --- L'étage 1 est terminé et sa sortie est démontrablement fausse en neuf points : des binaires réclamant libgpgme.so.11, libnettle.so.8, libicuuc.so.76 et six autres, aux versions de soname de l'HÔTE. L'étage 2 les dissout tous les neuf en reconstruisant chaque paquet contre ce que le dépôt livre réellement. La contrainte qui le façonne : pacman ne peut pas tourner dans le rootfs d'étage 1, libalpm ayant été lié contre le gpgme de l'hôte. Le rootfs est donc peuplé depuis l'EXTÉRIEUR, avec le pacman de l'hôte et --root, et le chroot ne sert qu'à bâtir. Ce n'est pas un contournement mais l'ordre qu'a le problème : la sortie de l'étage 2 est le premier pacman qui tournera sur la cible. Cinq paquets ont rejoint l'étage 1 pour cela, et le résolveur n'aurait jamais pu les nommer : rien ne DÉPEND de fakeroot ni de bison, ils sont simplement ce qu'il faut pour qu'une compilation ait lieu. makepkg refuse de tourner en root, le chroot porte donc un utilisateur avec l'uid de l'hôte — un bind mount conserve le propriétaire numérique, et un uid différent ne pourrait pas écrire $srcdir. Le smoke test sépare les échecs durs des dérives connues. makeinfo échoue parce que texinfo a été bâti contre le perl de l'hôte ; c'est précisément ce que l'étage 2 répare, donc refuser de démarrer pour cela serait refuser de lancer le correctif. Assisted-by: Claude Opus 5
211 lines
11 KiB
Bash
Executable file
211 lines
11 KiB
Bash
Executable file
#!/usr/bin/env bash
|
|
# Stage 1 of the port: build a self-hosting Arch `core` for s390x.
|
|
#
|
|
# THE THREE-STAGE DISCIPLINE, AND WHY IT IS NOT OPTIONAL
|
|
#
|
|
# Stage 1 builds with the HOST toolchain (Ubuntu gcc/glibc). Every package it
|
|
# produces is therefore linked against the host's glibc, not Arch's. That is
|
|
# acceptable -- and unavoidable, since Arch's glibc needs an Arch gcc which
|
|
# needs an Arch glibc -- but it is not a port yet.
|
|
#
|
|
# Stage 2 chroots into the stage-1 result and rebuilds everything with the
|
|
# stage-1 toolchain. Stage 3 repeats it, and a port is self-hosting once
|
|
# stage 3 reproduces stage 2. Skipping this leaves host artefacts baked into
|
|
# packages that will fail months later, far from their cause.
|
|
#
|
|
# This script is stage 1 only.
|
|
set -uo pipefail
|
|
|
|
HERE="$(cd "$(dirname "${BASH_SOURCE[0]}")" && pwd)"
|
|
source "$HERE/bootstrap-pacman.sh"
|
|
|
|
WORK="${WORK:-$HOME/work/arch-s390x}"
|
|
REPO="${REPO:-$WORK/repo/s390x}"
|
|
STATE="$WORK/stage1.state"
|
|
|
|
# Build order. It follows link-time dependencies, not pacman metadata:
|
|
# --nodeps means pacman never checks, so anything a compiler actually needs
|
|
# must already exist. Within a group the order is free.
|
|
STAGE1_PACKAGES=(
|
|
# Foundation: headers, then the C library, then the compiler chain.
|
|
linux-api-headers glibc binutils gcc
|
|
# Compression and crypto, needed by libarchive and curl further down.
|
|
zlib bzip2 xz zstd lz4 openssl
|
|
# Terminal handling: bash links against readline, readline against ncurses.
|
|
ncurses readline
|
|
# The shell, and the coreutils prerequisites Arch declares.
|
|
attr acl gmp mpfr libcap bash coreutils
|
|
# Text and file tools the build systems themselves call.
|
|
sed grep gawk findutils diffutils file which patch
|
|
# Archivers, then the library pacman reads packages with.
|
|
tar gzip expat libarchive
|
|
# Build systems.
|
|
m4 autoconf automake libtool make pkgconf
|
|
# pacman's network and signature stack.
|
|
libnghttp2 libpsl curl libgpg-error libassuan gnupg gpgme
|
|
# System skeleton: without these a rootfs has no /etc/passwd, no zones,
|
|
# no /etc/services -- and nothing boots to a usable shell.
|
|
filesystem iana-etc tzdata licenses shadow util-linux
|
|
# Named by the chroot test, not guessed. Installing the repo into a
|
|
# rootfs and entering it turned "does it work?" into a precise list:
|
|
# - libcap needs pam; openssl needs brotli; libarchive needs libxml2
|
|
# - pacman itself asks for systemd, pacman-mirrorlist and
|
|
# libmakepkg-dropins
|
|
# Sixty-eight successful builds proved none of this. One chroot did.
|
|
#
|
|
# The chroot also named libselinux, and libselinux is NOT on this line,
|
|
# because that reading of it was wrong. Arch has no libselinux package at
|
|
# all -- the clone 404s. What the chroot saw was a HOST artefact: Ubuntu
|
|
# carries libselinux1-dev, coreutils probes for selinux/selinux.h
|
|
# unconditionally, and ours came out linked to a library the target will
|
|
# never contain. The answer is --without-selinux per package, which is
|
|
# what Arch's own build chroot gets for free by not having the header.
|
|
pam brotli libxml2 systemd pacman-mirrorlist libmakepkg-dropins
|
|
# The closure, named by pacman's own resolver rather than guessed.
|
|
#
|
|
# Everything above was added because a BUILD stopped. These were added
|
|
# because scripts/test-chroot.sh ran `pacman -Syp` with --nodeps OFF --
|
|
# the check the whole bootstrap skips -- and the resolver listed exactly
|
|
# what the repository still owes. Nothing here is speculative.
|
|
#
|
|
# It is the MINIMAL closure, and two measurements shaped it. Dropping the
|
|
# python-brotli sub-package took the list from 70 unresolved names to 47
|
|
# and removed `python` outright, with libffi, mpdecimal and gdbm behind
|
|
# it. Dropping systemd-ukify and systemd-tests removed five more python
|
|
# packages, and ukify cannot run on s390x at all. Both are recorded in
|
|
# TODO.md rather than left implicit.
|
|
#
|
|
# An audit of the remaining names against the ARTEFACTS found two that
|
|
# were declared and never linked: guile by make, and libisl.so by gcc.
|
|
# Both get their declaration removed, because it should describe the
|
|
# binary we shipped.
|
|
#
|
|
# Building isl instead was the first plan, and it is recorded here because
|
|
# the reason it failed is the kind that wastes an afternoon: the Arch
|
|
# packaging repo for isl was last touched in 2017 and its only source URL
|
|
# is isl.gforge.inria.fr, which died with INRIA's GForge. There is nothing
|
|
# to build. That flipped the decision -- not a change of mind, new
|
|
# evidence.
|
|
#
|
|
# These will pull their own dependencies. That is expected: the resolver
|
|
# will name the next round as precisely as it named this one.
|
|
audit ca-certificates cryptsetup dbus elfutils gettext gnutls hwdata
|
|
icu jansson kbd kmod krb5 libcap-ng libgcrypt libidn2 libksba
|
|
libmpc libnsl libseccomp libssh2 libtirpc libunistring libusb libxcrypt
|
|
nettle npth openldap pambase pcre2 perl pinentry sqlite tpm2-tss
|
|
# Closure, second round. The first thirty-five pulled these in, exactly as
|
|
# the comment above predicted, and the resolver named them just as
|
|
# precisely.
|
|
#
|
|
# THE MEASUREMENT THAT MATTERS HERE IS THE ONE THAT CHANGED ITS ANSWER.
|
|
# Four of these were going to be avoided by dropping a sub-package --
|
|
# sqlite-tcl, sqlite-analyzer, the openldap server, debuginfod -- on the
|
|
# reasoning that had removed python-brotli earlier. Measured instead of
|
|
# assumed, tcl, unixodbc and libmicrohttpd each cost ZERO new packages:
|
|
# the closure had filled in around them. Building them is cheaper than
|
|
# four hooks, and it does not leave sqlite shipping an sqltclsh that
|
|
# cannot start.
|
|
#
|
|
# python still costs three (libffi, mpdecimal, gdbm) and is still avoided
|
|
# -- but for the ABI reason, not the cost one: python-audit and
|
|
# python-capng are cp313 wheels and Arch ships 3.14. Their hooks say so.
|
|
#
|
|
db5.3 gdbm e2fsprogs gnulib-l10n json-c keyutils p11-kit libsasl
|
|
libsodium libtasn1 libverto lmdb popt lvm2 tcl unixodbc libmicrohttpd
|
|
# ca-certificates-mozilla, which is the only thing here that is not a
|
|
# library. It is the LIST OF ROOT CERTIFICATES -- ca-certificates itself
|
|
# is only the trust machinery around it, so without this the target has a
|
|
# trust store containing nothing, and every HTTPS verification fails.
|
|
# curl declares ca-certificates, and pacman fetches through curl.
|
|
#
|
|
# It has no packaging repo of its own: the clone 404s, which
|
|
# gitlab.archlinux.org reports by asking for a login -- the same
|
|
# misleading shape that made libselinux look like a network problem. nss
|
|
# produces it as a sub-package, so nss is what gets built, and nspr comes
|
|
# with it.
|
|
#
|
|
# Measured before committing to it rather than estimated: nspr costs
|
|
# nothing new, nss needs only nspr plus mercurial on the host, and
|
|
# hg.mozilla.org answers from this build host (HTTP 302 in 0.3s -- worth
|
|
# checking, since dev.gnupg.org does not answer at all and libassuan
|
|
# needed a source change because of it).
|
|
nspr nss
|
|
# Closure, third round, and it is two packages. Both were pulled in by
|
|
# what the second round added, and both cost nothing further: libffi by
|
|
# libp11-kit, libevent by libverto.
|
|
#
|
|
# They are worth a line because of what they unblocked. p11-kit builds
|
|
# into three packages, and libp11-kit's dependency on libffi was holding
|
|
# up the whole chain ca-certificates -> ca-certificates-utils -> p11-kit
|
|
# -> libp11-kit. The resolver reported it as "ca-certificates required by
|
|
# curl" -- four links away from the missing name, and nothing in that
|
|
# message points at libffi.
|
|
libffi libevent
|
|
# Closure, fourth round -- and it closed to NOTHING, which is the point
|
|
# worth recording. It asked for libaio and thin-provisioning-tools, both
|
|
# wanted by lvm2 alone. thin-provisioning-tools is Rust now, so that was a
|
|
# language runtime arriving through a fourth-order dependency.
|
|
#
|
|
# Nothing in the repository wants `lvm2`. Checked across every .PKGINFO:
|
|
# cryptsetup wants device-mapper, and device-mapper is the OTHER package
|
|
# this same source produces. Dropping the lvm2 sub-package removed both
|
|
# entries and the Rust question with them -- see patches/pkgbuild/lvm2.sh.
|
|
#
|
|
# 35 packages, then 19, then 2, then 0. The closure has to be recomputed
|
|
# after each round rather than once: lvm2 DECLARED libaio all along, and
|
|
# the third round could not see it because lvm2 had not been built yet.
|
|
# What STAGE 2 needs in order to exist, which is a different question from
|
|
# what the repository needs to resolve.
|
|
#
|
|
# Stage 2 rebuilds everything INSIDE the stage-1 rootfs, so the tools that
|
|
# do the rebuilding have to be in that rootfs. The resolver never asked
|
|
# for these -- nothing in the repository depends on them -- so the closure
|
|
# rounds could not surface them. Enumerated instead from what makepkg and
|
|
# an autotools build actually invoke.
|
|
#
|
|
# fakeroot is the one that decides whether stage 2 can start at all:
|
|
# makepkg runs package() under it, and refuses to run as root. bison,
|
|
# flex, texinfo and groff are what the sources themselves call -- gcc,
|
|
# glibc and binutils all want makeinfo, and a great many configure scripts
|
|
# want bison.
|
|
#
|
|
# sudo is deliberately NOT here. makepkg needs it only for --syncdeps, and
|
|
# stage 2 passes --nodeps, so it would be a setuid binary in the chroot
|
|
# for no reason.
|
|
fakeroot bison flex texinfo groff
|
|
# And finally the package manager itself, built as an Arch package.
|
|
pacman
|
|
)
|
|
|
|
built() { grep -qxF "$1" "$STATE" 2>/dev/null; }
|
|
mark() { echo "$1" >> "$STATE"; }
|
|
|
|
main() {
|
|
mkdir -p "$WORK/pkg" "$REPO"
|
|
touch "$STATE"
|
|
# The stand-ins are read from /usr/local/bin, so a stage-1 run that never
|
|
# reinstalls them silently builds with whatever was deployed weeks ago.
|
|
# Cheap, idempotent, and it makes this repository the source of truth.
|
|
install_host_shims
|
|
local ok=0 fail=0 failed=()
|
|
for p in "${STAGE1_PACKAGES[@]}"; do
|
|
if built "$p"; then
|
|
echo "== $p already built, skipping =="
|
|
continue
|
|
fi
|
|
# A failure must not stop the run: one missing package should not hide
|
|
# the state of the forty that follow. They are collected and reported.
|
|
if build_package "$p" > "$WORK/log-$p.txt" 2>&1; then
|
|
mark "$p"; ok=$((ok + 1))
|
|
echo "OK $p"
|
|
else
|
|
fail=$((fail + 1)); failed+=("$p")
|
|
echo "FAIL $p (see $WORK/log-$p.txt)"
|
|
fi
|
|
done
|
|
echo
|
|
echo "== stage 1: $ok built, $fail failed =="
|
|
[ "$fail" -eq 0 ] || printf ' failed: %s\n' "${failed[*]}"
|
|
}
|
|
|
|
main "$@"
|